Sunday, November 30, 2014

Suddenly Unable to Breathe

A young man came to see me the other day complaining of several episodes of frightening shortness of breath. The first episode developed quickly one day when he was leaving work. He had been tired that week, perhaps with early symptoms of a respiratory tract infection or perhaps his allergies were acting up, but his distress seemed to come on “out of the blue.” Quite abruptly, he recalled, he couldn’t breathe. His symptoms improved relatively quickly, such that by the time he arrived home 30 minutes later he felt all better, although frightened by such a severe attack.

He experienced several similar events over the next few weeks, many waking him from his sleep. He had no prior history of asthma, although he had a history of mild seasonal rhinitis. He experienced occasional post-nasal drip and had no symptoms of heartburn to suggest gastroesophageal reflux. He had never been told of asthma as a child, and he was a lifelong non-smoker.

When questioned more about his difficulty breathing, he was quite clear: he simply could not get air in or out of his chest. It was not that it was hard to empty the air from his chest, he said, it was that no air would move at all. He was given an albuterol inhaler to try, but found it difficult to use and in truth had not tried it.

He reported only minimal cough, no sputum production. He had not experienced wheezing, but recalled a respiratory sound that he made as his episodes gradually resolved. His wife thought that she too had heard a breathing noise, particularly when he tried to breathe in. They have two cats at home but noted no increased likelihood of symptoms when around the cats. In the absence of these attacks, he felt well and was able to work out at the gym without limitation due to his breathing. His only medications were vitamin D and glucosamine chondroitin.

His chest examination was normal. Chest X-ray was normal. Breathing tests (spirometry) performed at a time when he felt well was likewise normal. And the question was: is this asthma?

Asthma causes symptoms that come and go. Between attacks one can feel entirely well with a normal chest exam and normal lung function. However, the history that this young man offered was atypical in several ways, including no prior history of asthma; sudden severe attacks that came on without warning and resolved within a few minutes without treatment; and his sense that during these spells it was not hard to breathe, but impossible to breathe at all – no air movement in or out at all. As the episode abated, there came an inspiratory sound; and when asked if he could localize the site of his distress, he offered that he thought his problem was in his throat more than in his chest.

The diagnosis? Not asthma but laryngospasm – an alternative and more plausible explanation for these sudden attacks of difficulty breathing. Imagine that some irritant triggers the vocal cords to suddenly come together and tightly obstruct the upper airway. One cannot breathe (or talk), and it feels as though one were about to suffocate to death. One tries to inhale or exhale, but no air can pass the closed glottis. After what seems like an eternity but is probably well less than one minute, the laryngeal spasm begins to abate. As the vocal cords begin slowly to move apart, one can start to get air passed, with an inspiratory sound that we recognize as stridor. At first air enters the lungs with increased resistance through the narrowed upper airway, but over several seconds, as the laryngeal muscles further relax and the vocal cords abduct fully, normal breathing is restored. The entire event is over in a minute or two, and no medication is needed (or likely to help). An inhaled bronchodilator might be more irritating to the larynx and should probably be avoided.

What causes some people to develop laryngospasm is not known. Our young man had a normal ENT examination with direct laryngoscopy to exclude a structural abnormality of the glottis. His laryngeal sensitivity developed without prior trauma or other explanation. Potential triggers that may set off spasm of the sensitized larynx include mucus draining from the posterior pharynx, acid refluxed from below, cough with secretions expectorated at high velocity, or oro-pharyngeal aspiration.

Preventing provokers of laryngospasm, such as laryngopharyngeal reflux, is an important treatment, especially in persons with frequent night-time episodes. Other management strategies that have been described include “rescue breathing” techniques taught by speech-language therapists; application of forward and upward pressure behind the earlobes and in front of the mastoid processes in what has been described as the “laryngospasm notch”; and, rarely, botox injections into the larynx.

In most instances, coming to understand the mechanism of the event is key to dealing with it: one needs to try to stay calm, attempt small breaths in through the nose, and perhaps visualize relaxation and separation of the vocal cords. Knowing that the spasm of the larynx will pass in a matter of seconds and that there will be no long-term harmful effect are the reassurances that we have to offer. Distinguishing these episodes from asthma attacks is also crucially important. Treatment with bronchodilators and corticosteroids will not bring relief or prevent episodes of laryngospasm. It only confuses the issue, obscures the diagnosis, and likely frustrates the sufferer.


  1. lungcure dot in is a top asthma specialist in Gurgaon and Delhi. If you are dogged with the diseases like breathlessness, wheezing, coughing, and any lung cancer disease, consult for better cure and treatment.

  2. Not being able to breathe is one of the scariest things you can experience. Granted it hasn't happened to me, even though I do have asthma. There have been a few times where it acts up, but nothing serious yet. That doesn't rule out the possibility of it happening. I would not like that to happen, so I think that getting some treatment would be best for me.

  3. Asthma specialist in Gurgaon Delhi is a top class clinic in Gurgaon . Ger cured by world class doctors and specialists for asthma and lung cancer related diseases. For more information visit

  4. Thanks for sharing all these knowledge with us. The people who are really facing the problem of shortened breadth or the problem is there in the normal functioning of lungs then he or she must try the Noni fruit juice in their regular diet. The women may take the women's choice noni juice in their regular diet to maintain good health as it is anti-bacterial,anti-inflammatory and antioxidant.

  5. Thanks for sharing such a informative blog,it really helpful for all who are suffering from asthma.

  6. Thanks for sharing good information Find best Pulmonologist in Gurgaon & view all details of Chest specialist in gurgaon

  7. Very nice blog!
    Glad to visit this blog. Very Informative blog!
    We can search for Best Ear, Throat & Nose doctor in Gurgaon and review instantly on ENT Specialist in Gurgaon

  8. Emphysema Treatment ought to include, obviously, eliminating exposure to emphysema-bringing about poisons. This includes more than the evasion of tobacco smoke. You ought to look at your everyday life and check for different wellsprings of poisons.

    My name is Mrs Tina Jose am from Mexico I have been suffering from asthma , i was leaving with it for years with inhaler but all I ever wanted was to get rid of it permanently until i was directed to Dr Okosun for herbal mixture he helped me with it then i took it for just one week now am physically fit all thanks to him he is one of the best herbalist if you have any similar health problem like asthma,diabetes, stomach ulcer and some other S.T.D contact him today on email

  10. Thanks for sharing this extremely informative article on breathing problems due to cough. I recently read about breathing problems on website called I found it extremely helpful.

  11. As a sign of gratitude for how my husband was saved from asthma , i decided to reach out to those still suffering from this.
    My husband suffered asthma and it was really tough and heartbreaking for me because he was my all and the symptoms were terrible, we tried various therapies prescribed by our neurologist but none could cure him. I searched for a cure and i saw a testimony by someone who was cured and so many other with similar body problem, and he left the contact of the doctor who had the herbal cure to asthma . I never imagined asthma has a cure not until i contacted him and he assured me my husband will be fine. I got the herbal medication he recommended and my husband used it and in one months he was fully okay even up till this moment he is so full of life. asthma has a cure and it is a herbal cure contact the doctor for more info on on how to get the medication. Thanks for reading my story

  12. Very helpful article for those who are suffering from asthma. Thanks for sharing this extremely informative and insightful article on breathing problems. I saw a similar article at and found that extremely helpful.